We love great critic scores, but nothing means more to us than reviews from our members—and we’re thrilled to share our Top 10 of 2024. From an under-the-radar library Napa Cab to blue-chip bottles like Billecart-Salmon’s iconic rosé Champagne, these are the can’t-miss wines that delighted our members the most over the past year, and they’re sure to delight you too.
Needless to say, these wines go fast. If one you want is sold out, be sure to sign up for Notify Me, so you’ll get word as soon as this bottle—or another by the same producer—is back in stock.
Also, check out more top-rated Member Favorites below!
Billecart-Salmon Rosé Brut Champagne (1.5 L)- 4.88
Champagne’s rosé icon, in magnum, boasts a near-perfect score from our members.
2011 Daniel-Etienne Defaix Vaillon Premier Cru Chablis- 4.85
Gorgeous 14-Year-Old Chablis Premier Cru from an icon—and iconoclast.
Sold out, sign up to receive notifications when wines from this producer become available.
2018 Chateau Lagrange Saint-Julien Grand Cru Classe Bordeaux- 4.62
This Bordeaux standout comes within a point of $800+ Haut-Brion and Mouton Rothschild
Sold out, sign up to receive notifications when wines from this producer become available.
Final Few!
2020 Granbazan Albarino Limousin Rias Baixas- 4.60
A revolutionary Galician-coast cuvée that displays a stunning Meursault-like richness and depth.
Final Few!
2017 Hoopes Family Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon Oakville- 4.59
From right across the street from To Kalon, Hoopes is one of our top Cabs of all time!
Quinta de la Rosa 20 Year Old Tawny Port Portugal (500 mL)- 4.58
A rich, nuanced 95pt Tawny that shows why Quinta de la Rosa is a renowned single-quinta port producer.
This wine is on its way! Sign up to receive notifications when it arrives.
2019 Zenato Ripassa Ripasso Valpolicella Superiore- 4.58
Zenato’s Ripassa ranks with member-favorite Amarones that cost multiples more.
Sold out, sign up to receive notifications when wines from this producer become available.
Final Few!
Bollinger Rosé Brut Champagne- 4.56
Painstakingly made Champagne icon, beloved by James Bond, stands alongside Krug and Cristal.
Final Few!
2014 Castellucci Cabernet Sauvignon Rutherford- 4.56
Who wouldn’t love a decade-aged, winery-direct single-vineyard Rutherford Cabernet?
Final Few!
2021 El Enemigo Chardonnay Mendoza Argentina- 4.56
This was the #1 Chardonnay of James Suckling’s Top 100 Value Wines AND his #6 wine overall.
